Custom Loyalty Cards
Matte Stamp and Punch Cards for Small Business
Turn first-time visitors into regulars with professionally printed custom loyalty cards. Whether you run a coffee shop, restaurant, nail salon, barbershop, bakery, or any service-based business, our custom stamp cards make it easy to reward your customers and keep them coming back. Printed on premium matte cardstock in 14pt or 16pt, at standard business card size so they live in a wallet, with full-color printing on both sides at the single-sided price.

Why Choose Printed Custom Loyalty Cards?
Loyalty cards for small business, on premium matte cardstock with a surface built for the way a stamp card actually gets used.
Premium Matte Cardstock in 14pt or 16pt
Custom Punch Cards That Cut Cleanly
Customer Rewards Cards With the Terms on the Back
Wallet-Size Stamp Cards at 3.5" × 2"
Loyalty Card Printing Prices
Every price below covers full-color printing on one side or both sides. There is no double-sided upcharge.
| Quantity | Square Corners | Per Card | Rounded Corners | Per Card |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 100 | $11.99 | $0.12 | $16.99 | $0.17 |
| 200 | $13.99 | $0.07 | $18.99 | $0.09 |
| 400 | $18.99 | $0.05 | $27.99 | $0.07 |
| 600 | $22.99 | $0.04 | $36.99 | $0.06 |
| 800 | $29.99 | $0.04 | $46.99 | $0.06 |
| 1,000 Popular | $35.99 | $0.04 | $55.99 | $0.06 |
| 2,000 | $69.99 | $0.03 | $99.99 | $0.05 |
| 3,000 | $99.99 | $0.03 | $139.99 | $0.046 |
| Quantity | Square Corners | Per Card | Rounded Corners | Per Card |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 100 | $13.99 | $0.14 | $18.99 | $0.19 |
| 200 | $15.99 | $0.08 | $20.99 | $0.10 |
| 400 | $22.99 | $0.06 | $31.99 | $0.08 |
| 600 | $29.99 | $0.05 | $43.99 | $0.07 |
| 800 | $34.99 | $0.04 | $51.99 | $0.06 |
| 1,000 Popular | $44.99 | $0.04 | $64.99 | $0.06 |
| 2,000 | $79.99 | $0.04 | $119.99 | $0.06 |
| 3,000 | $109.99 | $0.036 | $149.99 | $0.05 |
Full-color printing on premium matte cardstock is included at every quantity. Prices exclude shipping and tax.
- Single-sided and double-sided cost the same at every quantity on both tables above.
- Minimum order is 100 cards, and the tables run to 3,000 for busy storefronts. Every quantity is produced in 2 business days.
- 14pt is the everyday standard; 16pt lasts longer in a wallet. Both use the same matte surface, the same presses, and the same double-sided pricing.
- Need regular business cards too? See our 14pt glossy business cards and 16pt glossy business cards on glossy stock.
Why Custom Loyalty Cards Are Printed on Matte, Not Gloss
The surface is the whole point: a stamp has to dry on it, and a pen has to write on it.
A loyalty card gets marked, not just read. That is why we print these on matte cardstock rather than the glossy stock we use for business cards. A matte surface absorbs stamp ink cleanly instead of letting it sit on top and smear, so impressions dry fast and stay crisp, and less wait time at the counter means quicker service for every customer.
- Rubber stamps dry fast and stay sharp. The uncoated matte surface takes ink instead of repelling it, so a stamp does not smudge when the card goes straight back into a wallet.
- Hole punches cut cleanly. Thick 14pt and 16pt cardstock punches without tearing or leaving a ragged edge.
- You can write on it. Ballpoint, gel pen, and pencil all work, so staff can date a visit or note a reward by hand.
- Both sides print in full color at the same price. Put your brand on the front and the stamp grid, terms, and expiry on the back at no extra cost.
Design Tips for Stamp Cards and Punch Cards
A loyalty card has a job to do, so design it around the stamp.
- Leave the stamp boxes empty and unprinted. A stamp reads best on bare matte paper, so keep the grid as outlines rather than filled color blocks.
- Size the boxes to your stamp. Measure the stamp face first and leave a little margin around it, or staff will end up overlapping impressions.
- Say what the reward is, on the card. "Buy 9, get the 10th free" printed next to the grid saves your staff from explaining it every time.
- Use the back. It costs nothing, so put your address, hours, phone, social handle, expiry terms, and a line for the customer's name there.
- Keep text out of the punch zone. If you punch rather than stamp, keep the area you punch clear of anything you need to stay readable.
- Choose rounded corners for wallet life. A loyalty card is carried for months rather than handed over once, and rounded corners fray far less.
Loyalty Card File Setup Guide, 3.5 x 2
Submit print-ready files for fast, accurate production.
| Trim Size | 3.5" × 2" (standard US business card) |
| Bleed | 0.075" on every side, tighter than the usual 1/8" |
| Document Size with Bleed | 3.65" × 2.15" |
| Safe Area | 0.075" inside the trim line on every side, so 3.35" × 1.85" |
| Paper Stock | 14pt or 16pt Premium Matte Cardstock |
| Printing | Full color, one side or both sides at the same price |
| Corner Options | Square, or rounded at a 0.15" corner radius |
| Coating | None. Cards are intentionally left uncoated |
| Color Mode | CMYK only |
| Resolution | 300 DPI or higher |
| Fonts | All fonts must be outlined before saving (including PDFs) |
| Effects & Transparency | All transparency, shadows, and effects must be rasterized |
| Accepted Formats | PDF, JPG, PNG, Adobe Illustrator (AI) |
| Minimum Order | 100 loyalty cards |
| Production Time | 2 business days |
How to Order Custom Loyalty Cards
From upload to delivery in 4 steps.
Loyalty Card and Punch Card FAQ
Stamps, punches, thickness, turnaround, and shipping.
Will rubber stamps work on these cards?
Yes, and that is exactly what the matte stock is for. The uncoated matte surface absorbs stamp ink cleanly instead of letting it sit on top, so impressions dry fast and stay crisp rather than smudging.
Glossy and laminated cards are the opposite: ink beads on the surface and smears when the card goes back into a wallet.
Can I hole-punch them?
Yes. Both 14pt and 16pt are thick enough to punch cleanly without tearing or leaving a ragged edge.
If you punch rather than stamp, keep the area you punch clear of any text or logo you need to stay readable.
Should I choose 14pt or 16pt matte?
14pt is the everyday standard and the better value. 16pt is noticeably thicker and holds up better over the months a loyalty card spends in a wallet being pulled out and stamped.
Both use the same matte surface, the same presses, and the same double-sided pricing.
Can I add matte or gloss lamination?
No, and that is deliberate. Lamination is a plastic film bonded to the paper, and once it is applied the card can no longer be recycled as paper.
A matte loyalty card is meant to be stamped and written on, and a laminated surface would repel stamp ink and smear every impression.
How long does it take to print my order?
2 business days, starting once we have a print-ready file. Transit time is additional and depends on your region and the service you pick at checkout; see our shipping information.
Business cards are not part of our same-day lineup, which covers flyers ordered by 11:00 AM Pacific.
What is the minimum order?
The minimum is 100 loyalty cards, and the price tables run to 3,000. Because we print digitally, a 100 card order gets the same press, the same paper, and the same color quality as a 3,000 card order.
What if my cards arrive damaged?
Take a photo and send it to us through web chat, and we will reprint and reship your order as quickly as possible.
Design Templates That Make Every File Print-Ready
Download free design templates for all RedPrinting products. Each template includes the correct trim size, bleed, and safe margin, so your artwork prints exactly the way you designed it.
Sticker Templates
Individually cut stickers in every shape and size, plus multi-design sticker sheets.
Business Card Templates
Standard, mini, and square formats for every card design.
Flyer & Poster Templates
From handout flyers to large-format posters, print-ready at every size.
How to Use a Template
Four steps from download to a print-ready file.
Artwork Guidelines That Get
Every File Print-Ready
Every file submitted to RedPrinting is reviewed by a real person before it goes to press. This guide walks you through file formats, resolution, bleed, and cut lines, so your stickers, labels, and cards come out exactly the way you designed them.
We Print the File You Send
Design services are not offered. We print your artwork as supplied, optimized for press.
We print the file you upload. We don't redesign artwork, edit your text, or build print files from scratch, which is part of how we keep prices low and turnaround fast. What we do is prepare your file for the press: we check the size, bleed, and resolution, and make the technical adjustments needed for a clean print.
If a file cannot be printed as it is, we contact you by text, email, or both and ask for a corrected file. If we don't receive a print-ready file within 3 business days, we cancel the order and issue a full refund.
The Three Lines on Every Template
Understand these and your file will cut clean every time.

Accepted File Formats
Vector files give the sharpest results, but we accept high-resolution raster files too.
| Format | Type | Best For | Recommended |
|---|---|---|---|
| AI | Vector | Logos, text, line art, custom shapes | Best |
| Vector | Print-ready files with fonts outlined | Best | |
| EPS | Vector | Legacy vector artwork | Best |
| PSD | Raster | Layered photo-based designs | Good |
| PNG | Raster | Designs needing a transparent background | Good |
| JPG | Raster | Photographs and full-color images | Good |
| TIFF | Raster | High-quality scanned or photo artwork | Good |

- Outline your fonts: Convert all text to outlines or curves so typefaces render correctly on our end.
- Use CMYK color mode: Printing is a CMYK process. RGB files are converted automatically, and bright neon or vivid blues may shift slightly.
- Flatten transparency: Complex transparency and drop shadows can behave unpredictably; flatten them before exporting.
- Embed or attach linked images: Missing links are the most common reason a file gets sent back.
Image Resolution
300 DPI at final print size is the target.
Resolution is measured at the size the artwork will actually be printed. A 300 DPI image looks crisp on a 2-inch sticker but turns soft when stretched across a 24-inch poster. Always check the pixel dimensions against the finished size, not against how the file looks on screen.
Web images pulled from a website or social media are usually 72 DPI, which is roughly a quarter of the detail we need. Enlarging a low-resolution file doesn't add detail back. It only makes the softness more visible.
Low-resolution artwork? If your piece still reads clearly in print, we print it. If the text would be unreadable, we contact you and ask for a higher-resolution file.

Choosing Your Material
Where the sticker will live decides which stock to use.
- Waterproof and tear-resistant
- Resists fading from sun and weather
- Holds up on bottles, laptops, and cars
- Higher cost per sticker
- Thin, smooth, and easy to write on
- Noticeably lower cost per sticker
- Ideal for packaging, boxes, and mailers
- Not water- or weather-resistant
Clear stickers are printed on transparent vinyl, so the surface underneath becomes part of the design. They're waterproof, tear-resistant, and work beautifully on glass bottles, cups, laptops, and windows where a white sticker edge would look out of place.
Because there's no white backing, light colors and white ink behave differently than they do on paper. Designs with bold shapes, dark colors, or deliberate negative space tend to read best.
Setting Up Sticker Sheets
Multiple designs and sizes on a single sheet.
Sticker sheets let you print several different designs together on one backing sheet. Our sheet templates come pre-populated with placeholder artwork that you replace with your own files.

Common Mistakes to Avoid
The issues that most often send a file back for revision.
- No bleed on the background: Artwork that stops at the die line leaves white edges when the cut shifts. Extend it 0.075 inch past the finished edge, or 1/8 inch for large-format products.
- Text too close to the edge: Anything outside the safe area can be trimmed off. Pull text and logos at least 0.075 inch inside the die line, or 1/8 inch for large-format products.
- Low-resolution images: Artwork saved from a website prints soft and pixelated. Work from the original high-resolution file whenever possible.
- Live fonts not outlined: Fonts we don't have installed get substituted. Convert all type to outlines before exporting.
- RGB color mode: Vivid RGB colors can't always be matched in CMYK. Design in CMYK to see accurate colors from the start.
- Die line left in the artwork: The cut line is a guide, not a design element. Remove it or keep it on its own separate layer.
- Wrong template size: Make sure the template you downloaded matches the size you actually ordered.
From File to Finished Print
What happens after you place your order.
